The Big Lies Against Cuba
Opinion and Analysis
March 2010

Despite President Obama‟s declaration of his administration‟s desire to “seek a
new beginning with Cuba”, and to “learn from history, not be trapped by it” in April of
last year, Cuba has remained under attack by the U.S.

In January, new US air security policies included Cuba on a list of countries
whose air passengers would get extra security screening as they enter US territory.
And Cuba remains on the State Department‟s list of „state sponsors of terrorism‟,
notwithstanding the lack of any evidence of Cuban involvement in acts of terrorism.
Cuba has vigorously protested all of these unconscionable attacks.

In fact, Cuba‟s policies of internationalism have arguably been the most
politically advanced in the world. From the direct military intervention to help in the
defeat of Apartheid in southern Africa in 1988 (Cuito Cuanavale, Angola) to direct
medical aide and solidarity with Haiti (before the earthquake). Since the earthquake,
western media has been suspiciously silent on the exceptional role Cuba has played in
support of Haiti with more than 900 health care providers on the ground, the largest and
most organized contingent on the island.

Yet, one of the most disturbing new attacks against Cuba occurred late last year
when a host of prominent African Americans signed on to a so-called “…Declaration of
African American Support for the Civil Rights Struggle in Cuba”.
This misguided “declaration” accuses the Cuban State of racism. It cites the
imprisonment of a Dr. Darsi Ferrer, an active critic of the Cuban government, as an
example of racism in Cuba.

Dr. Ferrer was reportedly accused of attempting to establish a private medical
clinic outside of Cuba‟s world-renowned medical system, by receiving illegally obtained
construction materials. Whatever the case, Dr. Ferrer‟s situation should immediately
bring to mind the 50 year history of attempts by the US to subvert the Cuban Revolution
through internal dissent and direct attack harkening back to the Bay of Pigs invasion
and so on.

Certainly the struggle against racism anywhere in the world is of paramount
importance to all of humanity. But can this attack against Cuba under the guise of
fighting racism really be justified? We think not.
Many African Americans may not know about some of the unique features of
Cuban history even though African Americans and Cubans have a deeply rooted history
of solidarity with each other.

For example, during Cuba‟s first War for Independence from Spain in 1868,
plantation and slave owner Carlos Manual de Cespedes freed and armed the slaves on
his plantation and called on them to join the struggle for Cuba‟s independence. The
Afro-Cuban General Antoneo Maceo emerged as one of Cuba‟s most renowned
revolutionary leaders of all time. As a result of this struggle, slavery was abolished in
Cuba by 1886.

What a contrast to US history where the maintenance of slavery was a pre-
condition of unity between the colonies in the American fight for independence from
Britain. Although more than 5,000 Blacks fought in the American Revolution, legalized
slavery continued for nearly another 100 years.

And the US has historically played a role in maintaining racism in Cuba. The US
intervention and occupation of Cuba starting in 1898 during Cuba‟s second War for
Independence (1895) and where more than half the fighters were Black, re-established
institutional racism in Cuba. Under the intermittent US occupations there, Afro-Cubans
and women, as well as the poor, were barred from voting, holding elective office,
owning businesses, land, and etc. Sound familiar?

Most Cuban historians and scholars agree that the Cuban Socialist Revolution in
1959 abolished legalized institutional racism in Cuba. Cuba‟s revolutionary constitution
outlawed racial discrimination while open and public debate and education since the
revolution have tackled Cuba‟s history as an Afro-Cuban nation. However, the legacy
of 500 years of slavery, racism, and all forms of discrimination is difficult to completely
eradicate in just 50 years, especially while also under the US led attacks and blockade
against Cuba.

Even so, the conditions of all Cubans have improved under the covenant of the
socialist revolution in Cuba which has provided free education, free health care, land
for poor farmers, reduced cost rent and utilities, the elimination of unemployment, and
so on.

Racism, institutionalized or otherwise has not been abolished any place in the
world. Yet Cuba, in our view, remains a hopeful beacon in the western hemisphere that
humane societies can be constructed that provide the basis for the elimination of all
forms of discrimination, exploitation, and oppression.

Ashaki Binta
For the “Cuban Working Group”
Black Left Unity Network
You may contact the working group at: cubaworkinggroup@gmail.com
And documents from the Cuba Working Group may be viewed at:
www.blackeducator.org/cubasolidarity.htm

Cuba Working Group
A Committee of the
Black Left Unity Network
Contact: cubaworkinggroup@gmail.com
View our documents at: www.blackeducator.org/cubasolidarity.htm
Press Release
Contact:
Ashaki Binta, Co-Convener 203-379-7711
March 1, 2010

National: The Black Left Unity Network (BLUN) announces the formation of it’s Cuba
Working Group (CWG) today. The CWG is a national network of activists and organ-
izers who are concerned about the ongoing attacks against the nation of Cuba despite
President Obama’s proclamations of improving relations with the Cuban state in the
Spring of 2009.

Most CWG members have traveled to Cuba and/or have been active in Cuban
Solidarity work for many years and are familiar with the difficult challenges faced by
the island over the last 50 years.

One of the latest attacks against Cuba was generated in the Black community
late last year when a prominent group of African Americans signed on to a declaration
originated by anti-Cuban activists in Latin America who accused the Cuban state of
racism.

Signers of the accusatory declaration include preeminent figures such as Dr.
Julianne Malveaux, Dr. Ron Walters, actress Ruby Dee, film maker Melvin Van
Peebles, Dr. Kathleen Neal Cleaver, and Dr. Cornel West among many others.
A list of 60 notable African Americans signed on to the document.

“Our consideration is that the accusation of racism against Cuba is disingenu-
ous and is in fact intended to weaken solidarity between the African American commu-
nity and Cuba which has historically been very strong.,” said Alberto Jones, a member
of the CWG and a native Cuban residing in Miami.

“A further consequence of this attack would then be to increase the unjustified
pressure on the Cuban state to abandon its socialist character and eliminate the cru-
cial gains of the 1959 Cuban Revolution in providing education, healthcare, affordable
housing, and a healthy cultural life for the Cuban people,” the group said.

According to the CWG, the US government’s historic blockade and ongoing
programs to foment internal dissent within Cuba contribute significantly to weakening
the island nation’s ability to improve and advance the political, social, economic, and
cultural gains of the revolution including the elimination of all forms of inequality and
lingering remnants of slavery.

Despite this, says the CWG, Cuba has abolished institutional racism and has
considerably improved the lives of all it’s citizens since the revolution including nearly
eliminating illiteracy and vastly improving infant mortality rates to levels lower than
those in the US, especially among African Americans. The Cuban nation has officially
acknowledged that more than 60 percent of its citizens are of African descent.

“We believe that those who are concerned about racism in Cuba should be in-
creasing pressure on the US government to end the blockade and other illegitimate
attacks against that country, rather than signing on to specious accusations that do
nothing to help the people of Cuba,” the group said.

The Black Left Unity Network (BLUN) was formed in May of 2008 to strengthen
and revitalize the Black Freedom Movement in the United States. The BLUN Cuba
Working Group was instituted in January this year to help educate the African Ameri-
can community about the importance of Revolutionary Cuba in the international fight
against all forms of discrimination, exploitation, and oppression and about Cuba’s
historic solidarity with the struggle for freedom of the African American people.

This is from our good friends over at General Strike Comics

“When asked what changes they would like to see, most Cubans say they do not want a return to the capitalism in place before the revolution. Mostly they call for tweaks to the socialist system, focusing on economic needs, not political reforms.”

Cuba reflects on fifty post-revolution years

http://www.welt.de/english-news/article2942953/Cuba-reflects-on-fifty-post-revolution-years.html

When 70-year-old Communist Party member Amanda Gonzalez recalls life before the Cuban revolution, bitterness creeps into her voice.

She chokes back tears as she remembers her parents working long hours at dead-end jobs in a stratified society where the odds seemed hopelessly stacked against the poor and the rich showed little concern for their plight.

“Poor people at that time had nothing, and there were many poor. The rich only cared about profits and wealth,” she said, sitting at a table in her peeling, 19th century home in central Havana.

Now, five decades after the triumph of the revolution that toppled dictator Fulgencio Batista and put Fidel Castro in power on Jan. 1, 1959, the rich are gone and a social safety net is in place, but economic hardship remains.

Like many Cubans, Gonzalez is anxious for it to end.

“On balance, the revolution has been positive, but what hits me is the economic situation. We are forced to do illegal things to improve our lives,” she said.

As their country prepares to mark the revolution’s 50th anniversary on Thursday, Cubans complain about some things and praise others in their remade society.

They like the free health care and education which have helped make Cubans some of the longest-living, best-educated people in the Americas. They also appreciate the low crime rate and absence of dire poverty.

But they say that, despite the revolution’s lofty goal of economic justice, it is a struggle to survive on salaries that average $20 a month.

“I can’t live on my salary. I have to ‘invent’ because it can’t be done,” said teacher Pedro Perez, using a Cuban term for bending the rules to make ends meet.

Inventing means finding ways to augment one’s salary or to make it go further by buying goods, often stolen, on the black market where prices are cheaper than in the state-run stores.

It is not uncommon for vendors to go to offices or homes peddling goods either stolen from government enterprises or purchased for sale at a higher price. They have no trouble finding buyers.

Gonzalez said she uses the subsidized monthly food ration the government gives all Cubans to buy cigarettes for two pesos (8 cents), then sells them for 5 pesos (20 cents).

In a country where most private enterprise is forbidden, she said that trick to earn a few more pesos is against the law. “Everything is illegal,” she said.

The government staged a crackdown against the black market for food after three hurricanes wiped out 30 percent of Cuban crops this year, but the peddling goes on.

Officials blame many of Cuba’s economic problems on the U.S. trade embargo against the island, put in place in 1962 to drive Castro and communism from power. But they also say Cuban productivity needs to improve and President Raul Castro called on Saturday for new austerity measures, including fewer subsidies for workers.

REFORMS

When asked what changes they would like to see, most Cubans say they do not want a return to the capitalism in place before the revolution. Mostly they call for tweaks to the socialist system, focusing on economic needs, not political reforms.

Many say they’d like to be able to open their own business and have the right to buy homes and cars, all now mostly prohibited.

“I’d just like to make enough money to live off my salary,” said Perez.

But some call for broader changes such as multi-party elections, greater freedom of expression and more freedom to travel.

“We Cubans want freedom. Changes mean freedom,” dissident Oswaldo Paya said recently. “To deny changes is to close the doors of the future to the Cuban people.”

Younger Cubans, for whom the events of 1959 are ancient history, express greater dissatisfaction than their elders.

Prominent blogger Yoani Sanchez, 33, and rock musician Gorki Aguila, 39, have run afoul of Cuban authorities for their outspoken criticism of the government, and many younger Cubans are frustrated by the lack of opportunities.

Apart from the improved social services, 32-year-old Manny Garcia said “everything else about the revolution has been bad in my opinion.”

He scoffed at reforms Raul Castro initiated after officially replacing Fidel Castro as president in February. The changes included letting Cubans buy cell phones and computers for the first time.

“To allow Cubans to have cellular phones, I don’t see that as a change. When you lack everything else, a cellular is a luxury. I have to save for months if I just want to buy a pair of tennis shoes,” Garcia said.

Fidel Castro retired due to poor health but is still a powerful figure behind the scenes and his younger brother is not expected to push through radical reforms.

Argelio Gonzalez, a 61-year-old gardener with a cigarette hanging out of his mouth and a machete in his hand, said the young critics should not forget the conditions that created the revolution.

“The rich had everything and the poor had nothing, only misery,” he said.

As for change, “I don’t want any,” he said. “I want everything to stay like Fidel wants it.”

 

 

This is why we say that for countries like Haiti, socialism is the only path forward.  As dogmatic as that may sound, we know that the imperialists will never give Haiti enough scraps to feed their entire population.  Haitians will have to reorganize the entire country on an egalitarian basis so that the bare necessities are provided for all.  Playing games with the IMF and capitalist economic doctrines will never address the concerns of the starving masses in Haiti.  We know that pursuing socialism wouldn’t change things in Haiti overnight, but we must say that only on that economic basis will the vast majority of Haitians see improvement in their lives.

Meeting Cuba’s youngest politician

Liaena Hernandez

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/7784234.stm

As Cuba prepares to celebrate the 50th anniversary of Fidel Castro’s revolution on 1 January, most of those in power are the same people who fought alongside him half a century ago.

Fidel’s brother Raul Castro, 77, is now president and he chose 78-year-old Machado Ventura as his number two.

But there is a new generation of communists waiting in the wings.

The majority of deputies elected to the national assembly, or parliament, earlier this year were born after the revolution.

The youngest, Liaena Hernandez, is just 18 years old. A petite young woman with long black hair and an engaging smile, she has been a political activist since her early teens.

We first met during a coffee break at the last national assembly meeting.

“Having young Cubans in parliament shows that the revolution continues. It isn’t just something from our history,” she told me. Ms Hernandez comes from Guantanamo province at the eastern end of the island.

Her father is in the army and she has just completed her voluntary military service as a border guard in an all-female unit along the controversial US naval base at Guantanamo Bay.

She was born just as Cuba’s main benefactor, the Soviet Union, collapsed.

What followed was called the special period, a time of hunger and hardship. The United States also tightened the trade embargo believing it would hasten the collapse of communism.

This is the Cuba that Ms Hernandez grew up in.

Kissing babies

“I was born with the revolution. I’ve never known capitalism,” she said. “My earliest memories are of socialism, the special period and the US blockade.

Farmers in Manuel Tames are waiting for land reforms to pay off

“As a family we couldn’t have all the things we would have liked. For years I had to wear the same pair of shoes to school, we just had to keep mending them.

“But at least I had free health care and education. And as a nation, everyone was willing to work together to get by and move forward.”

Ms Hernandez invited the BBC to visit her on a constituency visit.

She represents Manuel Tames, a small rural community nestled in the foothills of the Guantanamo’s Sierra Cristal mountains.

There is little traffic on its dusty streets apart from horses and the occasional tractor.

At the heart of the town is an ageing sugar mill with its giant smokestack chimney. There is also a recently renovated health centre with nurses and beds to spare.

But solving constituency needs is not the primary role of Cuban deputies.

“Our most important mission is to explain to the people the politics of the state so that they understand what going on,” she explained as we arrived.

Some two dozen constituents had gathered to greet us outside of the municipal offices.

Like all good politicians, Ms Hernandez moved comfortably amongst them, kissing babies, joking and chatting with young and old.

Better roads and housing are amongst their concerns, but food appears the number one priority.

Raul Castro has started to hand over unproductive state owned land to private farmers and co-operatives in a bid to boost production and cut food imports.

Farmers in Tames are waiting expectantly for the scheme to take off.

“Today is a different period from that of the revolution. There were some things which were needed then which are not so good now, because the context has changes,” she said.

“We need to keep perfecting our economic system, that’s where the country is going.”

‘Perfeccionamento’

The government’s priority is to try and make the state-run system work more efficiently, rather than opening up to a free market, like the Chinese have done.

You hear the word “perfeccionamento” – perfecting the system – used a lot by officials.

There are also no signs of any political reforms. Opposition parties are not allowed.

The national assembly only meets twice a year, a few days of committee sessions followed by a single day’s sitting. Critics call it a rubber stamp parliament. The next session is scheduled for 27 December.

Candidates are also selected in advance. In the elections in January there were 614 people standing for the same number of seats.

You do not have to be a member of the Communist Party to stand, but it does help.

Ms Hernandez, though, believes that the system has served Cuba well.

“History has taught us that the Communist Party is the road that Cuba needs to follow.

“We don’t need to copy other countries’ systems. We are satisfied with our own and we are going to keep perfecting it.”